If you're an equestrian who sets horse riding goals but struggles to achieve them, you're not alone! It’s a common problem for many passionate horsewomen.

You might think that it's because of one of these reasons:

  • not enough time,
  • lack of confidence, or
  • even fear of failure.

But when you look deeper, the root of the problem often lies in mindset. The good news? Shifting your mindset can help you finally achieve your riding dreams.

1. The Mindset Trap: Self-Doubt and Limiting Beliefs

Many horsewomen unknowingly sabotage their progress with self-doubt. Thoughts like “I’m not good enough for my horse” or “What if I make a mistake?” create mental barriers that can feel impossible to overcome. These beliefs are often reinforced by past experiences, like:

  • a fall,
  • a bad round at a show, or
  • a negative comment from another rider, a family member, or even a coach

Solution: One way to reframe these limiting beliefs is through a technique called “anchoring.”

This involves creating a positive emotional state—such as confidence or calmness—and linking it to a physical action, like touching your reins or placing your hand on your thigh. 

To do this, recall a time when you felt truly successful (in riding or another area of your life). Bring that memory vividly to mind and pair it with your chosen action. Repeat this regularly to strengthen the association.

2. Fear of Failure (Or Even Success)

Fear isn’t always about falling off or getting hurt. Sometimes, equestrians fear achieving their goals because it means going into unknown, unfamiliar territory.

Success can bring new challenges, like increased expectations or pressure to perform.

Mindset Shift: Instead of focusing on the “what ifs,” focus on the “what now.”

Visualise yourself achieving your goal and notice how it feels.

What’s one small step you can take today to move closer to that vision?

Breaking big goals into manageable actions reduces overwhelm and keeps you moving forward.

3. Perfectionism Paralysis

Many equestrians (especially horsewomen of a certain age) believe they have to ride perfectly to be successful. This mindset creates unhelpful, unnecessary stress and often leads to avoidance behaviours, like skipping rides when they don’t feel “ready.”

Solution: Use reframing to change how you view mistakes. Instead of seeing them as failures, reframe them as learning opportunities.

For example, if your horse spooks during a ride, ask yourself, “What can I learn from this?” or “How can I use this experience to prepare for next time?”

Shifting your perspective makes it easier to move past setbacks and stay consistent.

4. A Lack of Clarity

It’s hard to achieve a goal you haven’t clearly defined. Many riders set vague intentions like, “I want to improve my riding” without specifying what that actually looks like. Without a clear target, it’s easy to lose motivation.

Mindset Shift: Use the SMART goal framework: make your goals Specific, Measurable, Achievable, Relevant, and Time-bound.

For example, instead of saying, “I want to improve my canter transitions,” say, “I will practice canter transitions three times a week for the next month and track my progress by recording my rides.”

This approach gives you a roadmap and keeps you accountable.

5. Negative Inner Dialogue

Your self-talk matters! Constantly criticising your riding or comparing yourself to others can erode your confidence and steal your joy of riding.

Solution: Replace negative self-talk with affirmations. Start with simple phrases like, “I am capable of improving,” or “My horse and I are a team.”

Write these affirmations down and repeat them daily, especially before rides. Over time, this practice can shift your default thinking patterns to be more supportive.

Bonus Tip: If you don't believe the affirmation, make it a question by putting "what if" in front of it. e.g. "What if, I am capable of improving?" Your powerful mind will look for an answer!

6. Overcoming Anxiety Through Mindset Techniques

Riding anxiety can make even the thought of getting in the saddle feel overwhelming. Whether it’s fear of cantering, jumping, hacking, or competing, anxiety often keeps riders from reaching their goals.

Mindset Shift: Use visualisation to calm your nerves and build confidence.

Close your eyes and picture yourself riding successfully. Imagine every detail—the rhythm of your horse’s movement, the sound of their hooves, and your steady breathing.

Visualisation primes your brain for success and helps you approach rides with a calmer, more focused mindset.

7. Accountability and Support

Riding goals aren’t meant to be achieved alone. Lack of accountability often leads to inconsistency and stalled progress.

Mindset Shift: Surround yourself with a supportive community of like-minded horsewomen who understand your struggles.

Share your goals and celebrate wins together. Having a coach or mentor can also provide guidance and keep you motivated.

Final Thoughts

Achieving your horse riding goals is about more than just skill—it’s about mastering your mindset.

By releasing fears, reframing challenges, and creating a clear plan, you can transform your riding experience.

Remember, every step forward counts, no matter how small. You and your horse deserve to enjoy every ride and achieve your dreams together.

Want help setting and achieving your horse riding goals? Join my FREE WEBINAR - From Stuck To Success: 3 Steps To Achieve Your Riding Goals in 2025

About the Author

Anne Gage, The Horse Riding Confidence Coach

Anne Gage, The Horse Riding Confidence Coach, began specialising in helping anxious horse riders after losing her own riding confidence while she was a professional riding coach and horse trainer!

As a recovered anxious rider, Anne knows what it’s like to be truly terrified to ride. She also knows how important the relationship between horse and rider is for confidence.

Anne’s unique coaching includes riding and horsemanship skills combined with qualifications in equine behaviour, NLP, and hypnosis. (But don’t worry, she won’t have you clucking like a chicken!).

Anne is a popular clinician, a regular contributor to Horse Canada magazine and The Rider, and the author of the book, Confident Rider Confident Horse.

Anne lives with her husband of 40+ years, 2 dogs, 3 cats, and 3 horses on their farm north of Orangeville, Ontario.

Find out more at www.confidenthorsemanship.com

7 Mindset Shifts You Can Make Now To Be A More Confident Horse Rider

Free Guide - 7 Mindset Shifts You Can Make Right Now To Be A More Confident Horse Rider

Struggling with your horse riding confidence? This free guide tells you about 7 common mindset shifts anxious horse riders can make to improve your horse riding confidence.

 YES! I NEED THIS